Ten Little Fish Review
"Ten Little Fish" is an adorable book with issues. Bruce Wood used computers to generate the beautiful illustrations. The story is very well written by Audrey Wood. The title is perfect as a read-aloud with very young children. The repetitive plot and rhyming words invite interaction. The book is especially useful for teaching children to count to ten. How can a book with so much going for it earn only four stars? At one point, a fish swims toward heaven. Why is religiously charged language used in a book available from a conventional school library and book store? Not everybody believes in heaven; such language is inappropriate in this environment. Was Wood really unable to think of anything else to rhyme with seven?
Before slamming the "not helpful" button, I'd like to leave the reader an afterthought. I want to make it clear that I don't believe that there is anything wrong with religious literature. The issue is that this book pretends to be a typical secular minded book, similar to the rest of Bruce and Audrey Wood's esteemed bibliography. False advertising or the lack of is the problem. If a parent is raising a child as a Christian, the issue that I raised here may seem invisible. So consider how your feelings for this book might change had the fish launched itself to Buddhist Nirvana, plane of the sky goddess or realm of the ancestor. For a counting book, why invoke the supernatural at all? While this title may just happen to align with your values, consider that unless a book is advertised for a niche market, it really should be for everybody.
Available at Amazon Check Price Now!
Related Products
- The Deep Blue Sea: A Book Of Colors
- Alphabet Rescue
- Alphabet Adventure
- Alphabet Mystery
- Three Little Fish And The Big Bad Shark
Customer Reviews
My son LOVES it! - A Reader - Seattle
I think this book is pretty weird, especially the last few pages and the page where a fish is snacking on potato chips. But my 20-month old son has been obsessed with it ever since we checked it out of the library 6 weeks ago. So here I am buying it, since I've run out of renewals at the library! My son has really enjoyed counting the fish and pointing out their colors (neither of which he can do well yet, but I suppose this book is helping him learn). I'm learning to accept that my taste in books may not always match my kid's!
One of The Few Adored by Both My Kids - New Mommy - Hamilton, New Jersey
I bought this for my son when he was 2ish (don't remember now). But he loved it back then (is now 5), Now it has been passed down to my daughter who absolutely loves it. The colors and illustrations are truly captivating and the story is fun. My daughter who is 23 months (and has loved the book for months) loves when one fish takes a break for a snack. My kids have had completely different tastes in books but this is one of the few books loved by both. Highly recommend it.
Great Book for Little Counters - Donna L. Anthony - Georgia
My son is 2 and loves to count. This is a great book for that with bright little fish swimming all around.
Great book!! - Patricia Crosier -
My daughter loves fish and this is one of her favorites. It's great for counting and the graphics are wonderful.
*** Product Information and Prices Stored: Aug 10, 2010 08:58:06
No comments:
Post a Comment